- News & comment
Financial scale of FTT charge will lead to a shift of business away from Europe
Publication date: 27 February 2012
Recent comments from the European Commission supporting the introduction of the FTT and survey results with positive public response to such proposals highlight that the public have not yet appreciated the very significant cost impact that the FTT would have on the long-term savings of EU citizens.
If applied at the start of 2011, EFAMA has estimated that the annual total impact of the FTT would have reached EUR 38 billion. Investors would have paid EUR 15 billion on the sales and redemptions of UCITS shares/units, whereas EUR 23 billion would have been levied on the sales and purchases of securities by UCITS fund managers. The share of money market funds in the total FTT revenue would have reached 67 percent.
These figures have been computed in a baseline scenario using the data for the sales and redemptions of UCITS shares/units in 2011 and the average turnover ratio of UCITS portfolios calculated for a large sample of UCITS distributed in Europe (0.9 for long-term UCITS and 6.5 for money market funds).[i]
These estimations show that the potential impact of the FTT would be significantly bigger than assumed by the European Commission. Taking into account the impact of the FTT on the value of derivatives transactions, the FTT-take would be even higher, in particular because many UCITS seek to remove currency exposure through hedging.
Furthermore, EFAMA has not attempted to quantify the multiple taxation effects due to the use of funds of funds structures and the use of multiple layers of financial intermediaries involved in the distribution of UCITS shares/units and the management of UCITS portfolios. It follows that EFAMA considers that its estimation of the FTT-take on the UCITS industry is likely to underestimate the real impact of the FTT.
Peter de Proft, Director General of EFAMA, comments:
“EFAMA hopes that its analysis will help increase public awareness of the extremely detrimental impact that the proposed FTT would have on the UCITS industry, its clients and the European economy.
It is clear that the FTT would put money market funds out of business and reduce the attractiveness of savings in equity, bond and balanced funds, thereby reducing an important source of long-term financing for the European economy. It would also cause retail and institutional investors to switch their savings away from UCITS and towards savings deposits and life insurance products that are not covered by the FTT in the Commission’s proposal. As this would distort even more the relationship between providers of long-term savings products and endanger the future of UCITS, and would ultimately reduce the choices available to EU citizens for savings, it is not an acceptable course of action. This would be totally unjustified in light of the reputation that UCITS has acquired as a model of excellence in the long term savings market.
The estimated total cost gives an idea of the revenue that would be levied if investors had no choice but to continue investing in UCITS. In reality, investors will be looking for alternative investments, a shift that will reduce the FTT revenue and affect the overall structure and growth prospects of the UCITS industry.”
[i] The estimation of the total impact of the FTT is reduced to EUR 34 billion in a scenario where the average turnover ratio is reduced to 0.5 for long-term UCITS and to 6.0 for money market funds. It would increase to EUR 45 billion if the average turnover ratio was increased to 1.5 for long term UCITS and to 7.0 for money market funds.
If you enjoyed this article, why not sign-up to receive our bi-weekly email newsletter?
- 2013 Capgemini & RBC World Wealth Report: (18 June 2013)
- Cambridge Mercantile Group to acquire the FX division of Raphaels Bank (18 June 2013)
- Thomson Reuters named calculating agent for new traded methodology (18 June 2013)
- Etrali Trading Solutions expands mobile recording offering (17 June 2013)
- Thanachart Bank selects Wolters Kluwer Financial Services’ IFRS solution (17 June 2013)